Left Brain vs Right Brain: The Kindle vs the iPad

The Apple iPad vs the Amazon Kindle debate rages on in the media and the blogosphere – with no end in sight.   The iPad fans proclaim that the Kindle is dead : it is no match for the rich, interactive, tactile interface of the iPad  - a superior, almost magical experience some call it.     The Kindle fans counter this view with well reasoned, rational arguments that list all the positive attributes of the Kindle – lower price, e-Ink display,  longer battery life, etc.   – and say that it is the perfect e-reader and will beat the iPad. So which side is right ?  Neither side  is –  the fallacy in all these arguments is that only one type of device can rule the market.   That is akin to someone proclaiming in 1984 – when the Mac was introduced that it would kill the PC  market or that the latest  DVD player from Sony would kill Panasonic.   Why is an e-reader different from these other consumer electronics devices ?   Isn’t this basic  Marketing 101 ?  Markets and consumers are not homogeneous – they are fragmented into many different segments – each one composed of different needs, tastes,  preferences, economics and demographics.
brain
The debate over the iPad and the Kindle however also highlights another  very interesting and subtle divide in tastes, preferences and attitudes – which I think influences  the way  companies design products and the way consumers react to products.   I call it the left vs right brain divide. Now I do realize that the left and right brained model – called brain laterlization – while popular is not as accurate as was once believed. Current research suggests that the brain is far more complex than such a simple  model  suggests.   It is however still a very useful  metaphor in conveying the differences in approach – so keep this in mind when you read what follows.  You may call it the Analytical vs the Designer approach if you prefer.

The first thing that grabs you about the iPad is its beautiful design – it is a perfect mix of form and function in an aesthetically appealing package.   The genius of  Steve Jobs is that he has perfected the art of conceiving and creating products that combine beauty and functionality in a seamless, holistic way. The iPad is visually appealing, intuitive,  fun,  invites play and  exploration and appeals to the artistic, creative side in all of us.  Those are the same attributes that characterize the right side of our brains.  As per the popular theory  -people who are “right brained” are said to be artistic, creative, dreamers, better at art  and visual communication than math and logic.   So if ever there was such as a thing a s a  ”right-brained”  company – Apple seems to fit that bill very well – with Steve Jobs being the ultimate right-brained CEO.   His whole approach to design is to iterate till  ”he falls in love with the device”.    And the iPad certainly is a device designed to appeal to the right-side of our brains – and it succeeds extremely well in doing that.

Kindle on the other hand  is a device that  seems to appeal to the the proverbial “left-side” of the brain.  In  a reasoned,  detailed comparison of individual features  of the Kindle vs the iPad – it comes out ahead as an e-reader.  It is the engineer’s design for an e-reader – an economical, minimalist, efficient design that gets the job done. It is the rational, left-brained choice for an e-reader. This is not surprising when you look at Amazon and Jeff Bezos.  Amazon is  well  known for its highly analytical approach to problem solving – driven apparently by Bezos obsession for detail and measurement.   So a product like the Kindle seems to be the perfect device that emerges from such an approach – it is the perfect “Left-brained” e-reader.

If you take this analogy further, you  will find “left-brained” thinking is dominant among many technology companies –  with Google being the prime example. Again not surprising considering most technology companies hire engineers,  and programmers – highly “left-brained” tasks.   In fact, Google exemplifies the pinnacle of “left-brain” thinking. Everything is measured and analyzed and split-tested with very little room for subjective design choices.  A designer who quit Google wrote in his blog “Google couldn’t decide between two blues, so they’re testing 41 shades between each blue to see which one performs better” !

So what is the point of all this ?   The runaway success of the iPhone and the iPad – seems to indicate that maybe some “right-brained” thinking may not be such a bad idea in the “left-brain” dominated technology world.

Enhanced by Zemanta
Print Friendly

Share Bookmark and Share

You may also like these posts:

  1. Top 10 Reasons Why the iPad will NOT Kill the Kindle Tweet There is a post on TechCrunch today about the Top 10 Reasons The Apple iPad Will Put Amazon’s Kindle Out of Business Certainly the iPad will give some competition...
  2. Could this be iPad’s Killer Application ? Tweet In an earlier post earlier post I countered the view held by many  that the iPad will kill the Kindle. I believe these two devices target different and...

  • http://usb3gvn.com USB 3G

    Excellent, I just passed this onto a colleague who was doing a little research on that. Thank for this imformation.

  • http://usb3gvn.com USB 3G

    Exellent review. It is good imformation to know more. Thanks for share!

  • http://usb3gvn.com USB 3G

    We hope that you find this information useful and look forward to assisting you in the future. Thank for this support.

  • http://usb3gvn.com USB 3G

    Oh yes, this is what I’ve been waiting for. Thanks for the help! I hope you will post exciting imformation more.

  • http://usb3gvn.com USB 3G

    Do you know? I found many website but I can’t see imformation for me. And now, I feel happy because your imformation is very useful. Thank you very much!. 

  • http://www.deletethissite.com Dean Berceir

    Love your site man keep up the good work

  • http://www.GateNetIRC.com Jonathan Clyatt

    Interesting post and good read, hit Google and doing some research on this topic. I look forward to reading more posts from you.

  • http://www.oxer.pl Katalog

    iPad is for snob ppl anyway :)

  • http://www.legalsoundz.com Legalsounds

    I wanted to thank you for this interesting I definitely loved every little bit of it. I have you bookmarked your web site to look at the latest stuff you post.

  • http://edtaapp.blog.com/ Neal Bartle

    Once again great Article. You seem to have a good understanding of these themes.When I entering your blog,I felt this .

  • http://rivalcrockpots.net Ted Nesbitt

    Great post and website! I have bookmarked it and will check back ofter. I also linked you to my site.

  • http://www.freeasecret.com Maryjane Grams

    Great post. Can’t wait to read the next ones :)

  • http://www.birthoftherepublic.com Obama

    This is a really good read for me, Must admit that you are one of the best bloggers I ever saw.Thanks for posting this informative article.

  • http://www.crofting.org/index.php/forums/member/12600/ Jewell Bruderer

    All I can say is continue to keep it up. This webpage is so required in the time when anyone just really wants to talk about how several persons someones cheated on their wife with. I mean, thank you for bringing intelligence back towards the internet, its been sorely missed. Wonderful things. Please keep it coming!

  • http://www.eurovoxsoftware.com Melony Adonis

    Cool and great, there is actually some good points on this post some of my friends might find this relevant, will send them a link, many thanks. Good blog! Really fantatic stuff here. Thanks

  • http://www.healthassurancenetwork.com Jay Vleming

    Great site!!!