Ideas & Insights on Technology & Life..

Category — Twitter

Twitter Changes Its Question - Finally (many months after I suggested it !)

I read recently that Twitter has finally changed their question at the top of the website to read “What’s happening ?” from the old one which said “What are you doing ?”

Here is the original post by @biz on Twitter’s blog

This change was of course covered by all major blogs including Techcrunch and Mashable among others.

It is interesting that Biz quotes the following reasons :
“People, organizations, and businesses quickly began leveraging the open nature of the network to share anything they wanted, completely ignoring the original question, seemingly on a quest to both ask and answer a different, more immediate question, “What’s happening?” A simple text input field limited to 140 characters of text was all it took for creativity and ingenuity to thrive. ”

I must be prophetic for I urged Twitter to make precisely this change and even suggested the same question as a better alternative tagline almost eight months back in  my Twitter updates and also posted a blog entry here

Maybe  @ev or @Biz were actually listening and decided to implement my suggestion ;) ? Or maybe great minds think alike :) !

Twitter Should Change their tagline from "What are you doing"..

Link to The original Tweet, posted Mar 27, 2009 :
“Isn’t is time Twitter changed their tagline “What are you doing? ” to something that reflects what most tweets are about ?”

Here are my suggestions for alternative tag lines that Twitter could use :

Alternative Twitter Taglines

Alternative Twitter Taglines

Note the alternative suggested above  ”What’s happening ?”   !

Well at least I have the satisfaction of knowing that I was ahead of the curve here  :) ?

December 14, 2009   No Comments

How Would You Explain Twitter to Your Grandmother ?

By now thousands of articles and blog posts have analyzed the reasons  for the appeal of Twitter.  They have sliced and diced it neatly into its various components - simplicity, brevity, openness, immediacy,  transparency etc. But if you have ever tried to explain  Twitter this way to someone who has never used Twitter,  you most likely got blank stares.

In fact recently I tried to explain what Twitter is to a friend’s mother  - who is in her eighties and is not computer literate. So I tried to come up with an analogy that could convey the essence of   Twitter to her without using any technical jargon.  And this is what I came up with :

“Twitter is like a giant cocktail party where  everyone is talking (tweeeting) or listening.  You can wander around and mingle with anyone and overhear all the conversations in the room as a steady stream of chatter.  You can also  pick anyone you find interesting  and hear everything they say (or follow them).    You can talk  to any of them and you can grab anyone else’s attention by  just tapping  them on the shoulder with a gentle t@p - that is a tap with an @  (or a mention) !    And if you  hear something interesting you  can just turn around and RepeaT it to everyone who is listening to you -   which would be a RT or a  retweet.  And if  someone finds what you say  interesting they can do the same.    And of course,  almost everybody who is  anybody  is there at this party  -  from Ashton Kutcher to Zappos CEO, Tony Hsieh -   leaders, politicians, CEOs, movie stars, journalists, atheletes,  colleagues, maybe even  your neighbor (and sometimes even their cat)  - and you can talk to any and all of them.   Plus it is a fun way to meet new people.  Which is why it is one of those parties no one wants to miss, and once you are there no one wants to leave.”

So how would you explain Twitter to your grandmother ?

November 8, 2009   No Comments

Microsoft, Google sparring over Twitter !

Microsoft, Google sparring over Twitter? Should be interesting… http://bit.ly/9JbJb

The explosive growth of Twitter has evoked great interest among both Google and Microsoft to acquire the company. For Google this would immediately fill the gap in their search of real-time results and give them an even bigger share of the search market. For Microsoft, this would be a way to gain a desperately needed competitive edge for Bing.   While this would be a huge win for either company, it may not be the best thing for Twitter itself.  I think the  real potential  of Twitter is yet to be fully realized and if it merges into either giant - this may be jeopardized.

April 9, 2009   No Comments

Isn’t is time Twitter changed the question in their tagline ?

I wanted to elaborate on  a couple of tweets I posted earlier about Twitter itself :

Isn’t is time Twitter changed their tagline “What are you doing? ” to something that reflects what most tweets are about ?”  (the original tweet is here http://twitter.com/arunshroff/status/1402055235 )

and also

” Ironic that what makes Twitter interesting is most tweeps NOT blindly answering “What are you doing?” ”

http://twitter.com/arunshroff/status/1402067219

I signed up for Twitter in early 2007 because the year-old website has created a buzz and I was intrigued to find out what it was about.   At that time it was pitched as a way for a way for friends to stay connected with each other by being constantly updated on “what they were doing” via short, 140 character, SMS-compatible updates or “tweets”. Great idea, I thought, but was not sure if I wanted to be updated 24×7 with the trivial  minutiae of my friend’s lives, as much as I loved and cared for them.  The reaction of most people was the same - why would you want to be constantly  updated on what someone had for lunch or how boring it was to be stuck in traffic.  No one’s life could be that interesting - at least to others, with the possible exception of Linday Lohan and Barack Obama !

Anyway, in the meantime Twitter kept growing and I kept reading rave reviews about it. So I had a sneaky suspicion that I must have missed something the first time around. So I logged in to my dormant twitter account almost a year later.  And this time around, I think I understood what Twitter was all about:

Although the Twitter tagline pointedly asks  ”What are you doing ? ” and wants  you to answer that question in 140 characters or less, most users I notice blithely ignore that question for the most part.  Rather they use  Twitter mainly to broadcast everything that they find  interesting or important enough to be shared with any0ne willing to listen.  It is seldom a mundane description of what they are  doing.  Sure there are the occasional inane  ”Sipping tea on the verandah”  type of tweets which address the original question and clog the twitter stream.   But more often it is either a link to a breaking news story, or a great website they found, or a quote they read, or their 140 character solution to global warming or the decline of western civilzation ! Now we are talking, I thought.

I mean can you imagine how very boring Twitter would be if everyone indeed blindly answered the question “What are you doing ? ”  It would surely be a death knell for the microblogging platform as users leave in droves.

Twitter, I suddenly realized is succeeding and becoming so popular precisely because it is not being used for its original design purpose !  In fact, I even think that this has been  a stumbling block in conveying what Twitter is all about to newcomers and possibly kept potential new users away.  My son and daughter who are both avid Facebook users do not have  Twitter accounts because  they don’t get  why anyone would need to broadcast and listen to updates on what they or their friends were doing all day.  Ironically, to get Twitter you have to get past this mental stumbling block, and once that happens you are hooked.

So Twitter is doing itself a great dis-service and mis-representing itself to potential new users.

Which is why I tweeted  : Isn’t is time Twitter changed their tagline “What are you doing? ” to something that reflects what most tweets are about

And here are some suggestions which I tweeted earlier as well :

#TWITTER Alternative Twitter Taglines “What’s happening?” , “Let us talk”, “Can we talk”, “Tweet away” Any other suggestions?

http://twitter.com/arunshroff/status/1395258804

I particularly liked the first one - What’s happening? as it captures the essence of twitter.  I have thrown this question into my Twitter stream but so far no suggestions have poured in.  I did try to send a message to Biz Stone and Evan WIlliams - but there was no response.

So what do you think  - @ev / @biz / @twitter ?

March 27, 2009   2 Comments